Imagination and innovation in choice and presentation of topic: (20 points) __________

• Is the topic one that can be adequately covered in the assigned length?
• Is innovation shown in choosing a topic and presenting it?
• Is the paper interesting to read?
• Does the paper emphasize concepts over terminology?

Organization and presentation of subject matter: (20 points) __________

• Are all parts present: title page, abstract, body of at least five (5) pages, references?
• Does the paper adequately cover its topic?
• Is its purpose clearly defined?
• Does the writer show good knowledge of the subject?
• Does the paper read like a serious, scientific paper?
• Is the paper well thought out?

Use of evidence to support paper's thesis: (20 points) __________

• Are points or discussions illustrated with good examples?
• Are contrasting arguments treated fairly?
• Does the discussion not raise unasked questions?
• Are figures or other supporting evidence present when necessary or useful?

Ability to use the English language: (20 points) __________

• Does the paper read well?
• Is it relatively free of grammatical errors?
• Is it free of redundant words or phrases?
• Is it adequately proofread?
• Is it free of spelling errors?

Use of references (A.P.A. format): (15 points) __________

• Are there sufficient references to support the information presented?
• Is the proper reference style used?
• Are statements of fact clearly cited, and listed on the references page?
• Are the references from diverse sources and include recent work?
• Do the references indicate thorough research/thought?
• Are the references valid and reproducible?

Does this paper meet my expectations of a college student? (5 points) __________

• YES 5, NO 0

Total __________